The kind folks at Scotty Cameron might be able to help with that:

If you have any questions or comments regarding orders, returns, or products, contact the Studio Store toll-free at (800) 214-0213 or by e-mail at: customersupport@scottycameron.com. Our representatives are available Monday through Friday between 8:00 AM and 5:00 PM PST, excluding the following holidays:

I agree with Chuck you can call or I believe the Pistolero is very close in weight and size.

IMHO

Is it taboo to put a Superstroke on a Scotty?

I’m wondering the same thing. I have a Phantom 9.5 and am considering a thicker grip. I have a Two-ball Odyssey putter with a 3.0 Super-Stroke grip and like the way it feels. Will I ruin the value of my putter if I ever want to trade in?

I’m wondering the same thing. I have a Phantom 9.5 and am considering a thicker grip. I have a Two-ball Odyssey putter with a 3.0 Super-Stroke grip and like the way it feels. Will I ruin the value of my putter if I ever want to trade in?

...the exact question I'm struggling with. I have a TFB2, all blacked out and love the setup and weight of it. My other, older scotty, I did put a superstroke flatso on it and feel like I had better head control with it than I do with my pistelero grip, especially on the 4-8 ft knee knockers... That said, like anything in this game, I strongly feel you should go with whatever setup helps you play the best golf. I'd also love to hear others opinions on this topic...great thread!

They also make a paddle grip which is more like the flatso if that's more your style

I'd get the matador midsize grip. Should be pretty darn close size wise. There's a couple different color options.

Scotty does make a Large matador grip. Not sure if it’s as big as some of those super stroke grips.